Okay, that's 5 judges so far:

Lizard - Graphical judge
CrazyMLC - Graphical judge, Lua

Roast Veg - General
Poor mans sniper - General

Petethegoat -


Pete, are you going for a general judge, or something more specific?

Maybe i can be the Efficiency Judge?
Something along the liens of good or bad coding, and ingenious workarounds.
edit: WAIT, i want to compete, and if being a judge doesn't allow that... count me out.

Sure thing. People should get points for the "under the hood" work that the mod depends on.

I'm sure pete would agree to being under the hood judge.

I don't understand why rv and pms are judges.

I'm surprised, but I guess it's first-come-first-served. Looks like I stumbled in at the right time then.

There will be certain "rules" to judging, so there shouldn't be any problems.

I thinking there could be 3 judging branches:

Graphics, Ini/Lua mechanics, and general stuff.

The General judges judge on the fun-factor of the mod, along with how well it fits the theme.

I'll get some rules and stuff typed up once the judge selection is final.

We have 6 judges ATM, I would like one more Ini/Lua mechanics judge.

So i'm guessing Sniper and I will just be playtesting this stuff without looking into the code? Sounds good to me, but of course i'd look in once the contest was over or i'd submitted my rating.

I'm happy to judge ini, as well as Lua.

Ah what ever, I'll take up the mechanics judge.
Since i don't have time with school to actually code/sprite an entry anyway.

Looks like we got ourselves a team now.

Final(ish) judge list:

Lizard - Graphics
CrazyMLC - Graphics and Mod Mechanics

dragonxp - Mod Mechanics
Petethegoat - Mod Mechanics

Roast Veg - Gameplay
Poor mans sniper - Gameplay

____________________
Judge jobs:
Graphics judges - Focus on the mod's visual and audio effects. Take into account spriting, use of particle effects and glows, and sound effects.

Mod Mechanics judges - After playing with the mod in-game, check out the ini code and Lua and look for interesting or unique coding/scripting tricks or work-arounds.

Gameplay judges - You guys only have to play with the mod, and rate it for fun factor, balance, usefulness, and any other related things in-game.

To all judges - Type up a few sentences noting things related to your judging area, and why you gave the mod your specific rating.
____________________

Another gameplay judge would be nice, but what we have now is good. I'll update the main post of this topic once the new contest starts.


Edit: Is it okay with the public if I'm a judge? I could be a general judge, looking at gameplay, graphics, and mechanics.

While I'd be fine with you judging, I'd prefer it if you entered.

Also, I'm outraged that MLC gets to judge two things.

That's twice the work plus he's only checking the Lua.

Aieee! It seems I'm the "seventh" judge. XD

Oh well, it's fine.