Still, I'm (IRL) 5'9" and only 130, which is a little under average, but I don't think this guy has 50+ pounds of muscle on him. (based on 145 being average for 5'8")

Uh venn you are built like a stick figure. 130 is a bit above the minimum average for your height. It's entirely possible for him to weigh 220 and it be all muscle sorry.

That's still a 33.4 BMI, which is obesity, sonny.

Okay venn BMI does not calculate fat percentage. You're a ♥♥♥♥ idiot.

Okay, lets say he has 30 pounds of muscle.

His BMI is still 28.9, which is almost obesity.

Venn that's not how the BMI works.

Why couldn't he just be like three inches taller?

Then his BMI would only be... still in obesity.

Okay, his character is on steroids, and a midget.

End of discussion.

I don't even know what the hell the rest of the posts on this page are ABOUT.

I am either starting up some sort of homebrew setting based on the core D&D fluff (mostly), or creating a PvP arena, or just making a new system for us to PvP in.

What I need is for you guys to tell me which one you really want. Making a system is probably going to take a while longer and still be little more than modified 3.5.

I would like the homebrew system for the core rules

I need a DM!
My friend was going to DM a game but ended up wanting to play himself, so I need a DM!
Just PM me.

Playing version 4

Your friend is a ♥♥♥♥. I also assume he is new to the game.

If the whole group is new, you could just run some of the one-shots that have been released recently. I don't know anything about them since I don't play 4E, but there is at least one dungeon for every level grouping 1-30.

We should all just play Neverwinter Nights 2.

I hear conflicting stories about that game.

I would rather run random one-shots, or Paranoia, or some sort of PvP.

I have a NWN2 fetish, so I'd be in on it.

I dunno Alenth, I play it with a bunch of friends and it really is quite enjoyable. There are settings for PvP settings, etc. So it's definatly worth looking into.